The IMF and the elephant in the energy sector
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is not wrong to say that Pakistan’s power sector subsidy regime needs reform. Any serious policy practitioner knows that the present tariff structure is fiscally expensive, administratively weak, and vulnerable to misuse. But the IMF is wrong in how it has framed the problem, sequenced the solution, and identified the culprit. Under the Resilience and Sustainability Facility, the government has committed to replacing the budgeted electricity tariff differential subsidy and cross-subsidy system with a targeted subsidy framework for low-income consumers, to be disbursed through the Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP) by the end of January 2027. On paper, this sounds neat. In practice, it risks becoming another exercise where the poor are asked to pay for the sins of the power sector’s political economy. Firstly, the IMF’s core assumption is analytically weak. It argues that better-targeted subsidies will reduce incentives for higher-income cons...