Federal Constitutional Court sets aside Class-IV appointments at Karak DHQ Hospital

ISLAMABAD: Expressing serious concern over a disquieting state of affairs in public appointments in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) on Friday ordered a departmental inquiry against delinquent officials of the District Headquarters (DHQ) Hospital in Karak to discourage such irregularities in the future.

Headed by Justice Syed Hasan Azhar Rizvi, a two-judge FCC bench also set aside the appointments of several Class-IV employees at DHQ Hospital Karak and ordered a fresh recruitment process to be completed within two months.

The FCC had taken up a set of appeals filed by Muhammad Bilal and others against the May 22, 2025, restraining order issued by the Bannu Bench of the Peshawar High Court (PHC) against these appointments.

“It becomes evident that the case in hand exposes a deeply disquieting state of affairs in the realm of public appointments, giving rise to competing claims over the same public posts and leaving the fate of two distinct groups of individuals in a state of uncertainty,” Justice Rizvi observed in a 13-page judgement authored by him.

Directs fresh recruitment within 60 days from existing candidate list

The controversy revolves around a recruitment dispute that began in February 2020 when Dr Fakhar-e-Alam, then medical superintendent of DHQ Hospital Karak, initiated a recruitment drive for Class-IV posts. A departmental selection committee (first committee) was constituted and held meetings on Feb 25-26, 2020, making certain recommendations. However, appointment orders could not be issued due to a restraining order from the PHC.

After Dr Fakhar-e-Alam was transferred on March 4, 2020, his successor, Dr Jamil Anwar, constituted a fresh selection committee (second committee) on Sept 17, 2020. The committee recommended candidates and issued appointment orders on Sept 19, 2020.

Later, the director general health, through two letters dated Sept 22, 2020, first cancelled and then held these appointments in abeyance, citing violations of the competent authority’s directions.

While deciding the matter, the FCC ordered the KP government to reinitiate the recruitment process for the same posts strictly in accordance with the law.

However, the newly constituted departmental selection committee will not advertise the posts afresh; rather, the selection process will be conducted on the basis of the list of candidates already invited by the first committee and available on record.

No candidate will be disqualified solely on the ground of age, provided that he met the maximum age requirement on the date of the advertisement—Feb 2, 2020 — and was otherwise qualified for appointment to the post.

The FCC ordered that the entire recruitment process be completed within 60 days from the date of the judgement and that compliance be reported to the court.

Published in Dawn, March 14th, 2026



from Dawn - Home https://ift.tt/U2a4nhQ

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

D.G. Khan lawlessness

THE latest attack this week on a D.G. Khan cement factory convoy by the notorious Ladi gang , which clearly intended to kidnap employees and extort ransom from the factory management, underscores the deteriorating law and order conditions in the district. The raid by criminals armed with automatic weapons, which followed a string of over 30 attacks on police in the area in the first half of 2025 by the banned TTP, is a grim reminder of the ever-deepening security vacuum in the area amid a jurisdictional dispute between law-enforcement agencies. The raid is evidence of the growing nexus between militant outfits operating in the area and local criminal gangs, often backed by powerful local tribal elders and politicians. Spiralling lawlessness underlined by numerous gang assaults on industrial establishments — as well as the kidnapping and killing of factory staff — in recent years speaks volumes for the operational freedom these gangs and militant outfits enjoy in the area. More dis...
Read more

Can Donald Trump serve a third term as US president?

President Donald Trump on Monday declined to dismiss speculation that he would seek a third term and said he hadn’t considered whether he would go to court to contest the US constitution’s two-term limit for presidents. Here is a look at the legal barriers Trump faces. What does the US constitution say? The 22nd Amendment states in part: “No person shall be elected to the office of the President more than twice.” The amendment was ratified in 1951 after President Franklin D. Roosevelt broke with a self-imposed two-term limit set by presidents since George Washington, the nation’s first. Roosevelt, a Democrat who was president during the Great Depression and World War Two, served a third term and then died months into his fourth term in 1945. Wayne Unger, a law professor at Quinnipiac University, said the Constitution was clear that presidents are limited to two terms of four years each. He said that while that had not been tested in court, any challenge by Trump would likely be ...
Read more

Will personally monitor Saudi investment projects, no laxity to be tolerated: PM Shehbaz

Image
Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on Thursday said he would personally monitor the completion of projects with Saudi investment, adding that negligence regarding these ventures was not acceptable. Chairing a meeting in Islamabad to review matters related to the visit of a recent high-powered Saudi delegation and Saudi investment in different sectors, the premier said the trip under the leadership of the Saudi foreign minister was the beginning of a “new era of commercial and strategic partnership” between the two countries, according to a statement from the Prime Minister’s Office. The meeting’s participants were briefed that the Saudi delegation discussed investment in mining and minerals, agriculture, energy, information technology and infrastructure development. They were also told that both sides had deliberated on making Pakistan a part of the global supply and value chain while the Saudi delegation had also praised Pakistan’s preparedness. The participants termed the arrival of ...
Read more